March 26, 2009 at 8:11 pm (Ethics, Jewish, Torah, mitzvot)
Tags: doing good, halacha, Jewish, Jewish journey, mitzvah, mitzvot
Ah now I am Jewish, all the hard stuff is behind me right? All I have to do is continue on living the way I have always been living? What changed? One day I was a goy the next a Jew. You cannot tell me that the day makes a huge difference.
So why not jump into doing all the halacha? Why not do all the mitzvot at once? Whoa nelly. I do not jump both feet into anything and with this I did not even have an idea where to begin. It is not even something I had ever encountered until a few years before.
So my wife and I (yeah we got married in there somewhere) decided that together we would start incorporating different mitzvot into our lives. (Since she is not orthodox we did not venture down the halachic path.) The first thing we did was to incorporate Shabbat into our lives. We made Saturday the day where our professional jobs were not allowed and we would not watch TV or use the computer. Slowly we added more and more things into our lives.
So now I want you to think of this situation. My family is all Christian or something like that and my wife’s family is a participating assimilated Jewish family who used to attend a conservative synagogue. My in-laws feel like they have put in their dues and now do as they please.
The more we do to incorporate Jewish traditions the more different we look to our families. Why don’t we just follow all of the halachic laws? Because that would and does skewer the relationship we have with our parents, family and community we participate in. We have been warned of becoming ”too” Jewish by the Jewish relatives.
I do not live in a Jewish world. I live in a world that contains a good number of assimilated Jews but it is an assimilated American world. Some would say “ah that is too easy if you really believed you would do it all and become orthodox.” I think that sentiment is not fair and very particularistic.
I am proud to be Jewish and I am proud of the participation and ways of my family and myself. It is perfect for where we are today. As I learn more I try to incorporate what I am learning. I am willing to stand out and be different but I am not willing to separate myself from my family and community as a strict halachic experience requires.
Outside of the orthodox world everything is done by my will power. I am learning everything new. The language, the customs, the rituals, the traditions – everything is new. It is not necessarily better than what I had before. My parents did a fabulous job of raising me. They are great parents and in their honour, do not deserve throwing everything out just because I picked a new way of doing things.
As I get all wrapped and emotional about the expectations of the relentless external eyes questioning “how Jewish are you?,” all I can think of is back off. We are all people. How we do our Judaism is way more important then grey line rules. Living as a good Jew in this world is more important then living as a rule abiding Jew secluded from the rest of the world.
If I can be so bold, don’t make excuses for what you do and don’t do. Just do what you do with intention. Make sure that everything you do is done with the full beauty of Judaism in your eyes. That may mean that you do not live up to expectations of your neighbors. However, the most important thing is your family and the community you surround yourself with. They all should see the beauty of the Judaism you practice.
Peace, Shalom
cross posted at Blog Midrash
6 Comments
February 23, 2009 at 10:10 pm (Jewish)
Tags: intention, kavanah, mitzvot, speed praying, wrestling with G-d
You have got to be kidding me? Speed praying? Praying in less than 18 minutes? It is sometimes referred to as “Rocket Minyanim or Matzah Minyanim (davening has to be finished within 18 minutes).
What does this do for you? Is it an expert level of kavanah? How can you possibly do the morning prayers with intention in 18 minutes? Are you really praying or just showing “good face” in the community so nobody thinks poorly of you not showing up to services?
Why does this bother me? I have a very hard time when I am told that I am not Jewish enough because I do not follow the “rules” in some orthodox fashion. Somehow this makes my judgemental side rise up and ask how this qualifies as “Jewish enough?” I did my time this morning. I’m good thanks.
Levels of Jewish participation:
- Inspired and moved by G-d to perform the mitzvot, pray in community and immerse one’s self with full intention
- Wrestling with G-d and the mitzvot, pray in the community and immerse one’s self with full intention
- Inspired and moved by G-d to perform mitzvot
- Wrestle with G-d and the mitzvot
- Jew with full intention
- Pray in the community
- Do as you please
Doing, praying just to fullfill the obligation is not the intention of G-d’s words. Yes it is better then just doing as you please but it is missing the mark.
How about spending 18 minutes meditating on G-d, people and the mitzvot you are going to do today? Let it move you to change the world. Let it make you connect with all G-d’s people. Do this all together and forget the speed praying.
Phew! I am off my soap box now. What do you think? Help me out here.
1 Comment
November 1, 2008 at 9:51 pm (Uncategorized)
Tags: book, mitzvah, mitzvot, The Year of Living Biblically, with intention
I have finished A.J. Jacobs’ book The Year of Living Biblically. I loved the book. He had a great way of pointing out things that happened on his journey.
I loved reading about how doing different things got easier and how he began to appreciate the rituals. He talks about appreciating prayer, Shabbat and the fact that he is more appreciative.
The thing that suprised me at the end of the book was that I felt really sad for him. I enjoyed so much of his spiritual journey that when the year was up I thought he would have continued with a new found truth. Reality is that this was just a project. Much of the things he learned and incorporated he seemed to just let go. Now he is done with the project he no longer needs these things in his life. I never expected to feel such loss for him.
A. J. and his wife July do practice more Judaism and have joined the Jewish community with more activities like going to temple. A.J. says that he will keep Shabbat. We’ll see. I would love for him to write something 5 or 10 years following his journey to find out what has stayed with him.
This all makes me wonder about the argument that just doing mitzot is enough. A.J. did them. He did not have the intention to keep them and make them his own and they seemed very easy to relinquish. I still think that without intention the mitzvot are hollow.
1 Comment
October 28, 2008 at 9:43 pm (Uncategorized)
Tags: biblical, book, chasidic, Jewish, mitzvot, secular
What does it mean to be Jewish? Does doing the mitzvot make you more observant?
What does it mean to be secular? Does doing chasidic halacha make you want to be more secular?
I am reading a book by AJ Jacobs called “The Year of Living Biblically.” I am loving this book. He is making me laugh out loud constantly. He is a secular Jew who has done nothing with Judaism accept put the Star of David on top of the Christmas tree. His family did not encourage any exploration of Judaism. Even his grandmother would walk by Chasidic people and stick her tongue out at them. Now he is try to do all the rules in the Bible over 1 year.
From the opposite direction on Sunday I went to a speaking engagement where the women talked about being raised Chasidic and leaving to the secular world. She left a world where everything was planned for her, even who she woud marry, to the secular world where everything is up to you. In the secular world she has dropped all of the ritual. She did not even fast on Yom Kippur.
Emotionally these two stories juxtaposed leave me very confused. I loved both stories. Neither help answer my questions and my wrestle very well but they do point me to a path of balance and moderation and that will be where I will take my story.
Where is that place that you are observant in a secular world? Can you be Jewish and engage in the secular world? This is my world.
1 Comment
August 13, 2008 at 10:33 pm (Uncategorized)
Tags: faith, intention, mitzvot, submit, tikkun olam
Have you submitted?
Do you have faith?
Submit:
” To yield or surrender (oneself) to the will or authority of another.” -Houghton Mifflin
Faith:
“complete trust, confidence, or reliance” -yourdictionary.com
To submit oneself seems to be a very difficult thing after growing up in the American culture. How can I submit? Doesn’t that go against the idea of self reliance? How do I approach this?
To have faith is very American. It is so easy to throw ones trust or confidence into something. This seems to be overbearing at times. The rationalist in me wishes there were a few more thinking than those with just faith.
What is it like to live in the United States with complete surrender to the will of G-d? Have you met the person who not only dives into tikkun olam but also performs all the mitzvot with complete surrender and intention? Is this possible for someone who identifies with the Reform movement or the Orthodox movement?
Leave a Comment